There is so much feeling for
children in the film that has been made from Harper Lee's
best-selling novel, To Kill a Mockingbird...so much delightful
observation of their spirit, energy, and charm as depicted by two
superb discoveries, Mary Badham and Philip Alfordthat it comes as
a bit of a letdown at the end to realize that, for all the picture's
feeling for children, it doesn't tell us very much of how they feel.
This is the one adult omission that
is regretful in this fine film that Alan J. Pakula and Universal
delivered to the Music Hall yesterday.
At the outset, it plops us down
serenely in the comfort of a grubby Southern town at the time of the
Great Depression, before "desegregation" was even a word.
Here we are brought into contact with Scout Finch, a six-year-old
girl who is a thoroughly beguiling tomboy; her ten-year-old brother,
Jem, and their widowed father, Atticus, who is clearly the kindest
man in town.
And for a fair spell it looks as
though maybe we are going to be squeezed inside the skin of Scout
and Jem as they go racing and tumbling around the neighborhood,
shrieking with childish defiance at crusty old Mrs. Dubose, skirting
with awe around the dark house where the mysterious Boo Radley
lives.
So long as the film is on this
level, the director, Robert Mulligan, achieves a bewitching
indication of the excitement and thrill of being a child.
It is when the drama develops along
the conventional line of a social crisis in the communitythe
charging of a Negro with the rape of a white womanthat the
children are switched to the roles of lookers-on. They become but
observers in the gallery as their father, played superbly by Gregory
Peck, goes through a lengthy melodrama of defending the Negro in
court and giving a strong but adult lesson of justice and humanity
at work.
And their roles are still those of
bystanders in a subsequent episode when they are attacked by a
vengeful Negro-baiter and brought to realize that the strange Boo
Radley is not a monster but a friend.
It is, in short, on the level of
adult awareness of right and wrong, of good and evil, that most of
the action in the picture occurs. And this detracts from the
camera's observation of the point of view of the child.
While this still permits vivid
melodrama and some touching observations of the children, especially
in their relations with their father, which is the crucial
relationship in the film, it leaves the viewer wondering precisely
how the children feel. How have they really reacted to the things
that affect our grown-up minds?
Horton Foote's script and the
direction of Mr. Mulligan may not penetrate that deeply, but they do
allow Mr. Peck and little Miss Badham and Master Alford to portray
delightful characters. Their charming enactments of a father and his
children in that close relationship that can occur at only one brief
period are worth all the footage of the film.
Rosemary Murphy as a neighbor,
Brock Peters as the Negro on trial, and Frank Overton as a troubled
sheriff are good as locality characters, too. James Anderson and
Collin Wilcox as Southern bigots are almost caricatures. But those
are minor shortcomings in a rewarding film.
TO KILL A MOCKINGBIRD
(MOVIE)
Directed by Robert Mulligan;
written by Horton Foote, based on the novel by Harper Lee;
cinematographer, Russell Harlan; edited by Aaron Stell; music by
Elmer Bernstein; art designers, Alexander Golitzen and Henry
Bumstead; produced by Alan J. Pakula; released by Universal
Pictures. Black and white. Running time: 129 minutes.
|