Newly donated papers shed light on Edward R. Murrow's war
broadcasts
HILLEL ITALIE
Sunday, February 12, 2006
NEW YORK (AP) - The Second World War radio broadcasts of Edward R. Murrow are
now regarded as high points in the history of journalism, vivid examples of
how the spoken word can bring home events of infinite horror and complexity
from thousands of kilometres away.
But when it came to preserving Murrow's scripts and other papers from that
time, few people had the foresight or the luck to think of history. Some
materials were lost when the Germans bombed CBS offices in London, where
Murrow was based during the war. Others were simply misplaced in the rush to
meet the next deadline.
But some, like a batch just donated to the Edward R. Murrow Center at the
Fletcher School of Tufts University, have also turned up quite accidentally.
Back in the 1980s, CBS TV's London bureau was cleaning out files when producer
Mark H. Harrington III spotted an unmarked "old brown envelope tossed
into a box of other old files," according to his widow, Kyle Good, a
former CBS producer and now a publicist with Scholastic, Inc.
"He was shocked when he opened it up," Good said in a recent
interview. "When he first found them, he talked about where he might
donate them, but I suspect he put them carefully away and just forgot about
them. I suspect he thought about it from time to time, but just never got
around to doing it."
Harrington died of cancer in 1998 and Good had thought little about the Murrow
documents until a colleague urged her to donate them. Both Anne Sauer, who
directs the digital collections and archives at Tufts, nor Murrow's son,
Casey, say they've never seen the papers before. Linda Mason, a senior vice
president at CBS News, said the network has no original documents - although
there are audio records - from Murrow's war years.
"They're a fascinating glimpse of Murrow's early years, when he was just
coming into prominence," Sauer says of the papers.
Murrow, born in rural North Carolina in 1909, joined CBS in 1935 and two years
later was transferred to London, where he served as chief of the network's
European operations. When war came, he became famous for his detailed,
emotional radio broadcasts from London during the German air raids, with bombs
often exploding in the background.
In 1950s, the dark-haired, chain-smoking Murrow went on to even greater fame
as a television newsman, notably for his attacks against Sen. Joseph McCarthy
- the subject of Good Night, and Good Luck, the George Clooney-directed film
that has received six Academy Award nominations. Murrow died of cancer in
1965.
The papers donated to Tufts include handmarked scripts of Murrow's London
radio programs, reflections on life in the bomb shelters and other materials
that reinforce his image as a journalist of grim passion and integrity.
In an undated, six-page manuscript, headlined Notes on the Way, Murrow frets
that people have "lost the ability to feel," that they prefer
stories of bravery to those of horror. He recalls returning to London after a
visit to Vienna, Austria, and trying to tell friends about what he had seen.
"The long lines of Austrians outside the banks and travel bureaux; the
screams and shots in the night; the looting of Jewish shops," Murrow
writes. "All those things were either disbelieved, or dismissed as things
that happened in a far away land to people who deserved what they got
anyway."
The longest document, at 19 pages, is called London Underground and appears to
be a working draft for a magazine-style broadcast about the city's bomb
shelters. The manuscript, heavily marked with cross-outs and handwritten
inserts, is an impressionistic survey that includes overheard conversations,
vignettes of shelter residents and a dismissal of media reports that the war
has had a levelling effect on London society.
"Tales are told of the Duchess who plays bridge with her servants; and
the man from the Stock Exchange who sleeps beside a taxi driver," he
writes. "Most of that kind of talk is nonsense. Your degree of safety and
comfort, and your underground neighbors still depend very largely on how much
money you have."
Casey Murrow believes London Underground may have been co-authored by Murrow's
wife, Janet. He says that the handwriting on the script was hers, and notes
that she often assisted his father on stories.
"She spent more time underground than he did and she might have been
asked to put in her ideas, too," says Murrow, who runs a nonprofit
educational organization in Brattleboro, Vt. "Dad actually avoided bomb
shelters because he was afraid if he started going into them he would never
stop going into them."
Another undated manuscript, titled News-Chronicle, presents a
behind-the-scenes account of Edward R. Murrow's radio broadcasts, from the
technology ("Twice each day a trans-Atlantic telephone circuit is opened
between London and New York") to British censorship ("It's always
well-mannered though sometimes stupid") to British character.
"These Londoners are a patient lot," Murrow observed, "and they
are sustained by a peculiar quiet arrogance - a feeling that they are superior
to other people."
He also reviews CBS war coverage, noting how the network reported
"semi-official promises" of progress in the war and offering a
statement of principles that recalls the high-minded speech framing Good
Night, and Good Luck.
"We have recorded British victories and defeats," he writes, ".
. . believing always that the intrusion of personal prejudice and prophecy is
useless if not harmful, and that the listener in America, if given sufficient
information will make up his mind in accordance with the ultimate truth."
© The Canadian Press, 2006