
|
|
In the United States, cigarette smoking and
smokeless tobacco together are the single leading preventable cause of
death. 1 Each year, tobacco kills over 400,000 Americans, more
people than are killed by AIDS, alcohol, car accidents, homicides, illegal
drugs, suicides and fires, combined. 2
Almost one million young people yearly, or
nearly 3,000 young people daily, become regular smokers. 3 As a
result, approximately one out of every three young people will die
prematurely from diseases related to tobacco. 4
Cigarette advertising has concerned the
Federal Trade Commission (FTC) since the 1930s, when it sought to prevent
companies from claiming health benefits from smoking (The FTC has general
authority to regulate deceptive or unfair business practices. The
responsibility is shared with the Department of the Treasury in regard to
alcohol advertising and the Food and Drug Administration in the area of drug
advertising.). But, there was little evidence to counter these health
benefits claims by tobacco manufacturers until 1938. Even during the
subsequent 15-year period, the agency issued only seven cease-and-desist
orders to eliminate various false claims.
Following the 1964 Report on Smoking and
Health by the Advisory Committee to the U.S. Surgeon General, and after a
long campaign by health education and consumer activists, the FTC concluded
that cigarette advertising that failed to disclose the health risks of
smoking was "unfair and deceptive." It proposed requiring clear and
prominent disclosure of cancer and other hazards on cigarette packs and
ads.
An alarmed tobacco industry put its first
advertising disclosures in place, but appealed to Congress for protection.
In 1965, Congress preempted the FTC by enacting legislation that called for
a milder and less prominent warning. Consumer activists then employed the
"fairness doctrine" of the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) to force
broadcasters to carry antismoking "countercommercials." As cigarette sales
began to slide, the tobacco industry, in the words of the chair of the
Tobacco Institute, "offered to discontinue all advertising on radio and
television." Congress "accepted that offer" in 1970, and tobacco
advertisements were banned from the airwaves starting on January 2, 1971.
1996 Tobacco Rule: Cigarettes as
"Addictive Drugs"
In August 1995, the Food and Drug
Administration (FDA) proposed a set of regulations designed to limit the
appeal of and reduce access to tobacco products. The proposed rules came
after a yearlong intensive FDA investigation of the role that nicotine plays
in young people's lives. The FDA found that cigarettes and smokeless tobacco
products are addictive drugs, which led them to conclude--for the first
time--that it has jurisdiction over tobacco products.
The proposed 1995 rules prompted more public
commentary--about 700,000 pieces of mail--than at any other time in the
history of federal rule making. After reviewing the public comments, the FDA
made several changes in the rule to focus their efforts exclusively to
minors.
In August 1996, President Bill Clinton
announced his support of the FDA rule, the nation's first comprehensive set
of regulations designed to limit the sales and advertising of tobacco
products specifically to minors. The goal is to reduce the consumption of
tobacco products by 50 percent in the next seven years. The move marks the
first time--and a strategic shift in policy--that tobacco regulation is
being considered by the FDA as opposed to the FTC.
According to The Advocacy Institute, a
non-profit agency located in Washington D.C., the FDA's regulations are the
most far-reaching attempt in United States history to limit the access to,
and appeal of, cigarettes and smokeless tobacco to children and
adolescents.
The program to regulate tobacco products
includes the following rules:
Reduce Easy Access by Children:
- Requires age verification for all
over-the-counter sales.
- Limits vending machine sales and
self-service displays only to places where minors are not allowed, such as
certain bars and nightclubs.
- Prohibits the sale of single cigarettes
and packages of less than 20.
- Prohibits free sampling of cigarettes.
Reduce Appeal to Children:
- Bans outdoor advertising within 1,000
feet of schools and playgrounds. Permits black-and-white text only
advertising for all other outdoor advertising, including billboards, signs
inside and outside of buses, and all point-of-sale advertising. Color and
imagery advertising is allowed inside places minors are not allowed to
enter.
- Permits black-and-white text-only
advertising in publications with significant youth readership (under 18).
(Significant readership is defined as more than 15 percent or more than 2
million. No restrictions on print advertising below these thresholds.)
- Prohibits the sale or giveaway of tobacco
products like caps, jackets or gym bags that carry cigarette or smokeless
tobacco product brand names or logos.
- Prohibits the brand name sponsorship of
sporting or entertainment events, but permits it in the corporate name.
Sponsorship of individual teams or entries within a sporting event is also
prohibited.
In addition to the final set of rules, the FDA
would require the nation's six tobacco companies with a significant share of
sales to children to provide strong educational messages for children on the
real dangers of smoking and using smokeless tobacco. This national
multi-media campaign would include television spots and would be monitored
for its effectiveness.
Suggested Citation:
Tobacco Advertising in the
United States . 1997. Issue Briefs. Studio City, Calif.: Mediascope
Press.
References:
- U.S. Food and Drug
Administration. (1996). Executive Summary: The Rugulations Restricting the
Sale and Distribution of Cigarettes and Smokeless Tobacco To Protect
Children and Adolescents, Rockville, MD: U.S. Food and Drug
Administration.
- Ibid.
- Department of Health and Human
Services. (1996). Press Release: President Clinton Announces Historic
Steps To Reduce Children's Use of Tobacco, Washington, DC: Department of
Health and Human Services.
- U.S. Food and Drug
Administration. (1996). op. cit.
Revised: March 9, 2000
Copyright 1997-2000 Mediascope |