|
Manufacturers' anti-smoking ads
ineffective-study
Tue 31 Oct 2006 21:01:41 GMT
By Maggie Fox, Health and Science Editor
WASHINGTON, Oct 31 (Reuters) - Television ads that tobacco companies say
are designed to discourage teenagers from smoking do no such thing, and
some may actually encourage youths to smoke, researchers reported on
Tuesday.
Their study of more than 100,000 U.S. teenagers show the ads may do more
harm than good, the researchers wrote in the American Journal of Public
Health.
"This study provides more proof that the tobacco industry is all smoke and
mirrors," said M. Cass Wheeler, Chief Executive Officer of the American
Heart Association.
"The tobacco industry is addicted to lying and in truth wants our kids to
become addicted to tobacco. If they were serious about reducing smoking
rates, they would stop spending $15 billion a year to promote their deadly
products."
Melanie Wakefield of the Cancer Council Victoria, in Melbourne, Australia
and colleagues at the University of Illinois at Chicago and the University
of Michigan got television viewing data from Nielsen Media Research.
They looked at the reach and frequency of tobacco company-sponsored ads
and whether they were seen by 12-year olds to 17-year olds in the largest
75 U.S. media markets, covering close to 80 percent of all U.S.
households, from 1999 to 2002.
They then looked at surveys of 8th, 10th and 12th graders in 48 states
collected in the same period for a study on tobacco use and beliefs at the
University of Michigan.
The data showed no correlation between frequency of the industry's
anti-smoking ads and actual or intended smoking by the teens.
"This research provides the clearest evidence to date that
tobacco-sponsored ads don't work," Wakefield, also with the University of
Illinois, said in a statement.
"Tobacco-sponsored ads targeted at youth have no impact and those targeted
at parents seem to have an adverse effect on students who are in their
middle and later teenage years."
DELAYING BUT NOT PREVENTING
The researchers noted that cigarette giant Philip Morris <MO.N> launched a
national $100 million television "Think. Don't Smoke" campaign in December
of 1998.
"Lorillard Tobacco Company also launched a U.S.-televised youth smoking
prevention campaign with the slogan, 'Tobacco is Whacko if You're a
Teen'," they added. Lorillard is owned by Loews Group <LTR.N>.
They noted that in one tobacco trial, Carolyn Levy, director of Philip
Morris youth smoking prevention programs, "admitted that the aim of their
programs was to delay smoking until age 18" -- not to prevent teens from
ever smoking.
In the survey, teens living in markets where many parent-oriented ads
aired were less likely to remember having seen such an ad, and were more
likely to say they might smoke in the future.
"It is conceivable that tobacco company smoking prevention ads could have
even greater adverse effects on youth smoking behavior than suggested by
this study," they wrote.
The Campaign for Tobacco-Free Kids said seven U.S. states had initiatives
on the ballot next week in nationwide elections that would raise tobacco
taxes, fund tobacco prevention programs, and require smoke-free workplaces
and public places.
"Just as they have sought to mislead the public with their fake prevention
programs and other deceptive tactics, the tobacco companies are now
spending tens of millions of dollars to mislead voters and defeat these
ballot initiatives," said William Corr, Executive Director of the group. |